| Year | Player | Award | Awards |
| 2002 | Chris Callahan | All-County | |
| R Kenneley | All-County | ||
| Nick Lochner | All-County | ||
| Ricky Palermo | All-County | ||
| Andy Veniskey | All-County | ||
| Joe Zaccardo | All-County | ||
| Josh Zenkel | All-County | ||
| 2003 | Chris Callahan | All-County | |
| Nick Lockner | All-County | ||
| Nick Marino | All-County | ||
| Ricky Palermo | All-County | All Greater Rochester | |
| Guermo Ruffolo | All-County | ||
| Tyler Scaccia | All-County | ||
| Andy Veniskey | All-County | ||
| Joe Zaccardo | All-County | All Greater Rochester | |
| 2004 | Matt Caternolo | All-County | |
| Nick Marino | All-County | ||
| Guermo Ruffolo | All-County | All Greater Rochester; All State | |
| Kyle Ruggeri | All-County | ||
| Kevin Sambor | All-County | ||
| Tyler Scaccia | All-County | All Greater Rochester | |
| Joe Zaccardo | All-County | All Greater Rochester; Player of the Year | |
| Josh Zenkel | All-County | All Greater Rochester | |
| 2005 | Robbie Brown | All-County | All Greater Rochester |
| Arron Canty | All-County | ||
| Matt Caternolo | All-County | All Greater Rochester | |
| Andy Episcopo | All-County | All Greater Rochester | |
| Nick Marino | All-County | All Greater Rochester | |
| Kyle Ruggeri | All-County | All Greater Rochester; Def. Player of the Year | |
| Eric Sheremeta | All-County | ||
| 2006 | Robbie Brown | All-County | All Greater Rochester |
| Matt Hodge | All-County | ||
| Alex Litto | All-County | ||
| Luis Ruffolo | All-County | ||
| 2007 | Kevin Episcopo | All-County | |
| Joe Franz | All-County | ||
| Chris Indovina | All-County | ||
| Rob Poliszuk | All-County | ||
| 2008 | Tyler Connaughton | All-County | |
| Lou Muscato | All-County | ||
| Rob Poliszuk | All-County | ||
| Eriksen Simmons | All-County | ||
| 2009 | Joe Franz | All-County | |
| Zerik Miller | All-County | ||
| 2010 | Jake Bolan | All-County | |
| Luke Geloso | All-County | ||
| Zack Smith | All-County | ||
| 2011 | Jake Altmire | All-County | |
| Nick DeFranco | All-County | ||
| Sergio Ruffolo | All-County | ||
| 2012 | Jack Bezek | All-County | |
| Max Kowal | All-County | ||
| TJ Syracusa | All-County | ||
| 2013 | Jason Indovina | All-County | |
| 2014 | Alex Hutchings | All-County | |
| Jason Indovina | All-County | ||
| Brenan Smith | All-County | ||
| Steven Zaccardo | All-County | All Greater Rochester | |
| Nick Zona | All-County | All Greater Rochester | |
| 2015 | Conner Wynn | All-County | |
| Pat Vandermark | All-County | ||
| Nick Zona | All-County | ||
| Robbie Schemp | All-County | ||
| Mike Schriener | All-County | ||
| 2016 | Sean Jones | All-County | |
| CJ Battaglia | All-County | ||
| R. Inguaggato | All-County |